Canada's Current Housing Market Makes Montesquieu Sad

When it comes to Canada's housing market, it's clear that something isn't quite right. The average home price has dropped, sales are in decline, and affordability is becoming a pipe dream for many Canadians. But, what if Canada were truly living up to its pluralistic reputation?

To delve into pluralism itself, we need to go back in time and meet Montesquieu. Also known as, Charles de Secondat, Montesquieu was a French political thinker and lawyer who lived in the 18th century. He is best known for his work "The Spirit of the Laws," in which he discusses his ideas on political theory, including the concept of pluralism and the separation of powers. This principle, which emphasizes the balance of power through checks and balances, is highly relevant to the current housing crisis in Canada and can be applied to understand and find solutions to the problem.

Montesquieu's philosophy of pluralism and the concept of separation of powers, offers a unique lens through which to view the current housing crisis. According to Montesquieu, the power of government should be divided among different branches and levels in order to prevent abuse of power and protect individual rights. In this context, the housing crisis can be seen as a failure of power balance among different branches and levels of government. The central bank, as an independent institution, has the power to make decisions on interest rates, but it is the role of the government to regulate the market and implement policies that would address the housing shortage and the inflationary pressures. Furthermore, the cooperation and balance of power among different branches and levels of government are crucial in order to address the housing and rent crisis and ensure that the different branches and levels of government are held accountable for their actions and that their decisions are made in the interest of the citizens.

The housing market has been affected by a perfect storm of factors; from the Bank of Canada's decision to raise interest rates, to the economic downturn caused by the pandemic. The increase in mortgage rates, as a result of the interest rate hike, has led to an increase in housing prices and a decrease in housing affordability for many Canadians. Additionally, the economic downturn caused by the pandemic has led to a decrease in demand for housing, which has further exacerbated the housing crisis. But, Montesquieu would argue that the solution lies in the cooperation and balance of power among different branches and levels of government. By holding each other accountable and making decisions that put the needs of citizens first, a solution can be reached. It is essential for the government to work closely with other branches and levels of government, as well as with the private sector and the community, in order to find a solution that addresses the housing crisis from all angles. This includes not just addressing the economic factors, such as interest rates and inflation, but also the social factors that contribute to the crisis such as lack of affordable housing options and lack of support for those struggling to afford housing.

Moreover, the government can also work on increasing the density of housing by relaxing zoning regulations and streamlining the building permit process. This will not only increase the supply of housing but also make it more affordable for the citizens. Additionally, the government can also invest in the construction of new public housing and provide tax incentives for landlords who choose to rent out their properties at below-market rates. 

To truly understand the depth of the crisis, it's important to look at the bigger picture. Comparative analysis of other countries and their housing markets can provide valuable insights and potential solutions. Germany's system of rent control and Singapore's system of public housing, have both effectively addressed the issue of affordability. Similarly, Denmark's system of land value taxation and the Netherlands' system of zoning have helped address the issue of housing shortage. These are just a few examples of the different approaches that have been implemented around the world to address the housing crisis.

It is imperative to acknowledge the fact that every nation possesses its distinct cultural and political milieu. While solutions employed in other countries may serve as a point of reference, it is essential to consider the contextual specificity of Canada. For instance, the relative vastness of Canada's territorial expanse in comparison to that of Singapore presents a formidable challenge in terms of increasing the density of housing. Furthermore, the legal and political systems of Canada may not be amenable to the implementation of a system of rent control. Thus, it is crucial to take into consideration these nuanced factors when evaluating potential solutions to the housing crisis.

Montesquieu's philosophy of pluralism emphasizes the criticality of the balance of power through checks and balances. This principle can be applied to the housing market as well. The government must establish measures that balance the interests of developers and landlords with the needs and rights of tenants and home buyers. This could involve the implementation of regulatory mechanisms and oversight bodies to guarantee that housing prices and rents are just and equitable, as well as providing assistance and support for individuals who are facing difficulties in affording housing.

One potential solution that can be adapted to Canada's context is the idea of community land trusts. Community land trusts are a type of non-profit organization that acquires and holds land for the benefit of the community. They can be used to create permanently affordable housing and to preserve land for community use. Community land trusts can be a powerful tool for addressing the housing crisis, as they help to ensure that land is used for the benefit of the community and not for speculative gain.

Another potential solution that can be adapted to Canada's context is the idea of inclusionary zoning. Inclusionary zoning is a policy that requires developers to include a certain percentage of affordable housing units in their new developments. This can be a powerful tool for increasing the availability of affordable housing, as it ensures that developers are contributing to the solution rather than exacerbating the problem.

It is without a doubt that addressing the current housing crisis in Canada requires a multi-faceted approach that takes into account the unique cultural and political context of the country. Montesquieu's philosophy of pluralism and the concept of separation of powers highlights the importance of cooperation and balance of power among different branches and levels of government in order to find a solution. Comparative analysis of other countries' housing markets can provide valuable insights and potential solutions, but it is essential to consider the specific context of Canada when implementing policies.

In addition to the solutions mentioned above, such as community land trusts and inclusionary zoning, there are other potential solutions that can be considered. For example, the government could invest in the construction of new public housing, or they could provide tax incentives for landlords who choose to rent out their properties at below-market rates. Additionally, the government could work to increase the supply of housing by relaxing zoning regulations and streamlining the building permit process.

Ultimately, it is important to remember that the housing crisis is not just an economic problem, it is also a social problem. The lack of affordable housing affects not only the financial well-being of individuals and families, but also their physical and mental health, their ability to access education and job opportunities, and their overall quality of life. Therefore, it is essential that the government takes a comprehensive and holistic approach when addressing the housing crisis.
​
By taking a comprehensive and holistic approach and working closely with other branches and levels of government, the private sector and the community, a solution can be found that addresses the economic and social factors that contribute to the crisis and ensures that everyone has access to safe, affordable, and decent housing. In addition, by taking a creative, innovative and cutting-edge approach, the government can create new and exciting opportunities to solve the housing crisis and make Canada a more inclusive, equitable and socially just society.